Talking to Fr Robert Hart and company. I don’t reflexively bash them but their long-standing position (Grafton’s) is an earlier version of Episcopalianism — so what’s to stop history repeating itself? — not Catholicism.
Fr Laurence Wells on American RCs. 1. Real social justice (not the modern left) + the legit liturgical movement + orthodoxy = Catholic. 2. The old immigrant-labour-Democrat tie is hard to break (why many American churchmen think the party line is doctrine) but you’re right that the party line is not doctrine. 3. As I say, Pope Benedict had better have the ex-ACs’ back; they’ll need it!
Scratch a libprot and find a nativist. But I appreciate the point about the inconsistency of hiring and giving benefits to the divorced and remarried. A counter-argument from my libertarianism: the divorced and remarried are consenting adults. Not so an orphaned or abandoned child the state tries to order the church to put into a homosexual couple’s home, against the church’s teachings.