Monday, August 18, 2014

RIP Bishop Børre Knudsen, and Catholic/Orthodox threads

  • Norway's defender of life Børre Knudsen dead at 76. Lutheran bishop. Well done, good and faithful servant. Bishop Knudsen was known throughout Norway and beyond for his gentle demeanor but uncompromising struggle against legalized abortion, beginning when the Norwegian law was adopted in 1978. Protesting the law, he refused to carry out government duties assigned to state church pastors, such as keeping official records, and refused his salary, but continued his pastoral service to his congregation. This protest was modeled after the Church’s resistance against the World War II Nazi occupation of Norway. When the occupation government attempted to transform the Church along their lines and brainwash children as was then being done in Germany, the bishops wrote a Confession known as “The Church’s Foundation” (Kirkens Grunn). This confessed that the Church is bound to God’s Word, that Word and Sacrament cannot be reshaped by the government, and that parents must resist government efforts to pervert their children’s faith. Knudsen continued to serve his parish despite government efforts to remove him, until the Norwegian Supreme Court ruled against him in 1983. He was not, however, defrocked at that time and continued his ministry in a valgmenighet, a Norwegian form of congregation nominally within the state church, but independent of its bishops. On Easter Day 1991, Knudsen and several other pastors formed the Strandebarm Deanery (Prosti), also called the “Norwegian Church in Exile.” The Deanery viewed itself as continuing the historic faith and practice of the Norwegian Church, but outside the control of the government and the government-appointed bishops. It held to confessional Lutheran positions, and thus opposed the state church, on such matters as abortion, homosexuality, and ordination of women. Knudsen was consecrated bishop for the Deanery in 1997, and this led to his being defrocked in 2001. He continued serving in the Deanery until 2011, when he retired for health reasons. Bishop Knudsen led an increasingly controversial series of protest actions in defense of the unborn as long as his health permitted. He was the object of much hatred and abuse by militant abortion supporters. He maintained a gentle but steadfast attitude in the face of much persecution. His family, especially his children, were also targeted for persecution.
  • Apostolic succession.
  • Parishes: to be ethnic or not to be ethnic? The tension between particularity and universality is part of small-o orthodox ecclesiology.
  • When one of the other side's saints has left the church. Classic byzcath reaction. The Byzantine Forum and the www.byzcath.org site ... are unofficial, have no connection with any Church entity, and should not be looked to as a source for official information for any Church. Then it shouldn't be byzCATH. A spinoff thread. P.S. I was being sincere to Mr. Vernoski, "Administrator"; making peace.

9 comments:

  1. Bad Catholic10:33 pm

    The gooey passive-aggressive Easternese of "Theophan" makes me want to jam a prayer rope down his throat.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Then it shouldn't be byzCATH."

    That's precisely right -- false advertising.

    Just tell the truth about who you are as a Church -- don't try to use Catholic language or the name to pass yourself off as something you aren't.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right; if you're relativists in Byzantine drag with a liturgical fetish, say so. Don't steal our name.

      Delete
    2. Bingo.

      Delete
  3. Part of the problem with Orthodoxy is that it is essentially a religion of negation. They define themselves towards the West oppositionally. We on the other hand can look at them as brothers and sisters. I like our way best!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly.

      Orthodoxy's annoying not just because I fell for it but unlike Anglicanism, the rest of the mainline, or liberal Catholicism, it's a sin that tries to appeal precisely to the orthodox in the West.

      Delete
  4. The advantage the Orthodox have over the Anglicans: valid sacraments and an organic development of their religion. Anglicanism is fabricated and its sacraments other than baptism and matrimony are null and utterly void.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right. The Anglicans are Other; the Orthodox have bishops and the Mass, and have never dogmatized heresy. They're part of our family turned against us.

      Delete
    2. Right about the Orthodox. Not fake at all, but incomplete because they marched out of the main house and took over a distant part of the property with the help of interlopers (tsars and sultans).

      Delete

Leave comment